|
|
I WILL COME AGAIN - APPENDICES
APPENDIX A Listing of Every Scripture
in which the Greek Word Parousia Occurs
The following is a listing of every
scripture in which the Greek word parousia occurs. (It is correctly
translated presence in this listing): "What shall be the sign of thy presence?"
Matthew 24:3 "So shall also the presence of the Son of Man be." Matthew
24:27, 37, 39 "They that are Christ's at his presence." 1 Corinthians
15:23 "What is our hope, or joy, or crown of rejoicing? Are not even ye,
presented before our Lord Jesus Christ at his presence?" 1 Thessalonians
2:19 That "he may establish your hearts unblamable in holiness before
God, even our Father, at the presence of our Lord Jesus Christ." 1 Thessalonians
3:13 "We which are alive and remain unto the presence of the Lord shall
not precede them which are sleep." 1 Thessalonians 4:15 "Be preserved
blameless unto the presence of our Lord Jesus Christ 1 Thessalonians 5:23
"Now we beseech you, brethren, by [respecting] the presence of our Lord
Jesus Christ, and our gathering together unto him." 2 Thessalonians 2:1
"Then shall be revealed the lawless one, whom the Lord Jesus shall slay
with the breath of his mouth, and bring to naught by the manifestation
[epiphania] of his presence." 2 Thessalonians 2:8 See R.V. "Whose presence
is after..." 2 Thessalonians 2:9 "Be patient, therefore, brethren, unto
the presence of the Lord." James 5:7 "Be ye also patient; establish your
hearts: for the presence of the Lord draweth nigh." James 5:8 "The power
and presence of our Lord Jesus Christ." 2 Peter 1:16 "There shall come
in the last days scoffers [in the church], walking after their own lusts
[desires], and saying, Where is the promise of his presence." 2 Peter
3:3, 4 "And hasting unto the presence of the day." 2 Peter 3:12 "When
he shall appear, we may have confidence, and not be ashamed before him
at his presence." 1 John 2:28 "For his letters, say they, are weighty
and powerful; but his bodily presence is weak, and his speech contemptible."
2 Corinthians 10:10 "Wherefore, my beloved, as ye have always obeyed,
not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out
your own salvation with fear and trembling." Philippians 2:12 "I am glad
of the presence of Stephanas…" 1 Corinthians 16:7 "God…comforted us by
the presence of Titus; and not by his presence only…" 2 Corinthians 7:6,7
"Through my presence again with you…" Philippians 1:26, Marshall's Greek
Interlinear
APPENDIX B Origin and Scriptural
Evaluation of "The Seven-Year Tribulation" Theory
Many hold the "seven-year tribulation
theory, which briefly states is this: Christ secretly returns to earth
to "rapture" the church and takes them to heaven. This will be followed
(not necessarily immediately) by seven literal years of tribulation during
which the "man of sin" enters upon the world's stage. At the close of
the seven years, Christ returns publicly with the church ("every eye shall
see him"), destroys antichrist and the false prophet and begins his Millennial
Reign. There are variations of the "seven-year tribulation" theory. Some
feel Christ gathers the church at the middle of the seven years and call
their concept the "mid-tribulation rapture." Others hold that the church
is taken after the tribulation and refer to their concept as the "post-tribulation
rapture." The "seven-year tribulation" theory has its roots in dispensationalism
which in turn originated, not in historic Protestantism, but in the 1800's
with J.N. Darby, the leader of the major segment of Plymouth Brethren,
a wonderful group of people, but hardly representative of historic Protestantism.
Even more disconcerting is that Darby revived the counter-reformation
views of a Spanish Jesuit named Ribera. A basic concept of the Reformation
was that Papacy as a system was the Antichrist and that much of the book
of Revelation was having its fulfillment during the history of the church.
In 1590 Ribera published a commentary on the Revelation, as a counter-interpretation
to Protestantism, in which he applied all but the earliest chapters of
Revelation to the end time and that Antichrist would be a single evil
person (not a system) who would rule the world for three and a half years
during the end time. Darby claimed that all the events from the sixth
to the nineteenth chapters of Revelation occur during a "seven-year tribulation."
However, nothing in the book of Revelation say or even hints that the
seven seals are loosed, the seven trumpets sounded and the seven plagues
poured out during a seven-year period. A seven-year period is not even
mentioned in the book Revelation. To be sure, a 3½-year period is mentioned.
However, nowhere is it indicated to be half of a seven-year period. It
can be easily proven from Scripture that the 3½ years occur before the
tribulation. (See the section "Daniel Chapter 7" in Chapter VI). Therefore,
the reformers such as Wycliffe, Luther, Calvin, Wesley believed the 3½
years or 1260 days were symbolic of a 1260-year period which began before
their time and extended to the "time of the end." The "seven-year tribulation"
concept rests solely on an inconsistent application of Daniel 9:24-27,
which speaks of a seventy-week period determined upon the Jewish people.
Seventy weeks equals 490 days. All agree, upon the basis of Ezekiel 4-6-a
day for a year-that this seventy weeks equals not 490 literal days, but
490 years. Again, there is unanimity that the 69 weeks of Daniel 9:25
marks a period from a decree issued in Nehemiah's day to the first advent
of Christ. Verse 26 states that "after" the 69 weeks "shall Messiah (Christ)
be cut off." Verse 27 shows that "in the midst of the [70th] week he [Christ]
shall cause the sacrifice and the oblation to cease." Christ's death abolished
the necessity of the further offering of typical sacrifices by Israel's
priesthood. Note well that Daniel 9:26 states "after" the 69 weeks "shall
Messiah [Christ] be cut off." The Hebrew word achor means after. It does
not mean in or during. Yet those who advocate the seven year tribulation
say that Messiah was cut off in or during the 69th week. This is a mis-translation
of verse 26 which plainly states "after" the 69 weeks Christ would be
cut off. The 70th week is after the 69 weeks and verse 27 clearly shows
it is in the midst of the 70th week that Christ died. Therefore the seven-year
period of the 70th week is not left over until the end of the Christian
age. And thus the seven-year tribulation concepts falls. The historic
position of Protestantism for 300 years since the Reformation has been
that the 70th week immediately followed the 69 weeks and was fulfilled
with the death of Christ "in the midst" (middle) of it. In the 19th century,
dispensationalists came along and said, "Not so, there is a parenthesis
between the 69 weeks and the 70th week. This gap is the period between
the first advent and the rapture. Then, they say, "The 70th week, seven
years, begins to count. And the 'he' of Daniel 9:27 is not Christ, but
anti-christ, and the seven years of the 70th week is the 'seven-year tribulation'
during which Chapters 6-19 of Revelation are fulfilled." The mere fact
that this gap is purely an assumption, not founded on Scripture, seem
to matter little to the seven-year dispensationalists.
APPENDIX C Every Scripture
in which the Word "See" Occurs Relative to Seeing at His Second Advent
Matthew 24:30, 31 "And then shall
appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven; and then shall all the tribes
of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds
of heaven with power and great glory. And he shall send his angels with
a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from
the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other." As has been shown
in Chapter V, Matthew 24:30-31 cannot be taken literally. The following
is a Scriptural analysis of the symbols in this highly figurative passage.
Heaven and Heavens
Isaiah 34:2-5, 8, speaking of
the destruction during The Day of The Lord, states that "all the host
[multitude] of heaven shall be dissolved…and shall fall down…for my sword
shall be bathed." (Verses 4 & 5) The literal heavens do not contain a
multitude of people. But the people in the symbolic heavens {the corrupt
religious systems) will be punished {symbolized by his sword drenched
in blood) by the returned Lord. Joel 2 describes The Day of the Lord.
Verses 9-11 speak of a great army that causes the earth to "quake" and
the heavens to "tremble." Literal heavens do not tremble before an army,
but revolutionary forces will terrify and overthrow the nominal church
heavens. The heavens of Joel 2:10 must be the same as in our text of Matthew
24:29-31, for in the heavens of both scriptures the sun and the moon are
symbolically darkened.
Clouds
Joel 2, a parallel scripture to Matthew
24:29-31, reveals that clouds, symbolize trouble. In Joel 2:1, 2 there
is reference to the "clouds" that become distressingly ominous in the
early dawn of the Lord's new day. "A day of clouds and of thick darkness,
as the morning spread upon the mountains; a great people and a strong;
there hath not been ever the like, neither shall be any more after it,
even to the years of many generations." It will be noted from this that
the "clouds" which appear in the early dawning of the day of the Lord's
presence really consist of "a great people and a strong," the like of
which has never before been known. This is evidently a reference to the
uprising of armed forces so tremendous that civilization will crumble
and fall under the impact of the revolutionary struggle they will precipitate.
These clouds of trouble are even now visible.
See
It has already been established that the
Greek word optomai can mean mental perception (Chapter V).
Angels
The word "angel" in the Greek,
aggelos, literally means "messenger." Often it refers to the angelic host,
but it can just as appropriately refer to any messenger of God. For example,
the returned Christ is symbolized by an angel that binds Satan for the
1,000 years (Rev. 20:1-3).
Trumpets
The word "trumpet" is used in Scripture
to symbolize a proclamation of truth. In the context of speaking the
truth clearly, Paul said, "If the trumpet give an uncertain sound, who
shall prepare himself to the battle?" 2 Corinthians 14:8 Again Joel
2 parallels Matthew 24:30, 31 and reveals the symbolic meaning of this
trumpet. From verse 1 we learn that it is a proclamation of truth that
warns the people of The Day of The Lord. In Zephaniah 1:14 and 16, The
Day of The Lord is spoken of as the "day of the trumpet," in which a
warning of truth is given "against the fenced cities, and against the
high towers [vested interests of the present evil world]." This trumpet
in Matthew 24:31 is evidently the same as the "last trump" of 1 Corinthians
15:52 and the trump of God in 1 Thessalonians 4:16, since all three
are related to the return of Christ. This trumpet is symbolic of a great
proclamation of truth at Christ's return.
Four Winds
Revelation 7:1 speaks of winds from the
four corners of the earth that, when loosed, result in great destruction.
Loosing of four winds would produce a whirlwind, which is another symbol
used in scripture (Jer. 25:32; Isa. 66:15-16) to describe the final
and severest phase of the "time of trouble" (Dan. 12:1). Now that we
have determined from parallel scriptures the meaning of the symbols
in this highly figurative passage, Matthew 24:29-31 becomes easily understood.
In answer to the disciples' query on the signs of his presence (Matthew
24:3), Jesus listed a number of events that have always been true of
history; "wars and rumours of wars"; "nation shall rise against nation";
famines, and pestilences, and earthquakes." Then Jesus said "all these
are the beginning of sorrows [or tribulation]." There are no unusual
events. They are common to history. Then in Matthew 24:29 he says "Immediately
after the tribulation of those days [the common tribulation of history]"
something is going to happen in the heavens. "The powers of the heavens
shall be shaken." Drastic changes will rock the nominal church heavens.
"The sun [the gospel sun] shall be darkened, and the moon [Mosaic Law]
shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven." The
Gospel (New Testament) and the Mosaic Law (Old Testament) were always
under attack from those outside the church. evelation 12:1 shows the
sun and the moon have always been the sustaining power of the woman,
the true church. But the phenomenon of our time is that the Bible (Sun
and Moon) is under attack from modernist within the church who deny
the divine inspiration of Scripture. {A survey taken among delegates
to the National Council of Churches revealed that over one third could
not state they had a firm belief in God.) Stars can symbolize either
faithful or unfaithful teachers. These "stars" which "fall from heaven"
represent false teachers who gravitate from a spiritual to an earthly
ministry on a political and social level. Indeed, the powers of the
heavens are shaking. The battle between the fundamentalist and modernist
has sorely rent the church heavens. The God-is-dead theology was but
one example of this shaking. Since Vatican II, Catholicism is also being
sorely rent. Verse 30, "And then [after the tribulation of those days]
shall appear the sign [Greek, semeion, evidence] of the Son of man in
heaven." One of the first evidences of Christ's parousia, presence,
will appear in the nominal church heavens. It is the darkening of the
sun and moon, and the fall of the stars. When we see a wholesale attack
by leaders in the churches on the divine inspiration of the Bible, and
ministers falling from a spiritual condition to a political or social
gospel, then we know that Christ has returned. From Joel 2:9-11, we
saw that it is agnostic revolutionary forces that are shaking the heavens.
Indeed, their philosophies have influenced theologians to reject the
Bible and degenerate to political battle. This was reflected in the
recommendation of the Conference on Church and Society (Detroit, 1968)
that the churches should support violence if necessary to achieve social
change. These revolutionary philosophies are also shaking the earth.
Revolution has been on the march since the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917.
Revolutionary and counter-revolutionary forces erupted into World War
II. Then followed the Communist takeover of one third of the world.
The flame of revolution spread throughout Africa and Asia as oppressed
nations threw off the yoke of colonialism. We are witnessing the black
revolution, the sex revolution, the youth revolution. No wonder the
Luke account (Luke 21:25, 26), when speaking of the shaking of the heavens,
adds, "Upon the earth distress of nations, with perplexity; the sea
and the waves [the restless and lawless elements] roaring; men's hearts
failing them for fear, and for looking after those things which are
coming on the earth [society]; for the powers of heaven [nominal church]
shall be shaken." The roaring sea and waves symbolize the restless masses
of humanity (Isa. 57:20), curbed but not full restrained, by the laws
and regulations of society. Everyone has heard some of this "roaring,"
with occasional stormy outbreaks dashing like tidal waves against the
earth (social order) and seeking to swallow it up. Restrained for a
time, these waves are gathering weight and force; and, as prophetically
shown, it is only a question of a few years until all the mountains
(kingdoms) are "carried into the midst of the sea," in anarchy. Psalm
46:2 In this connection Matthew 24:30 says, "all the tribes of the earth
mourn" as they "see" the Son of man coming in the clouds [trouble] of
heaven," (and "earth," Luke). This unprecedented trouble has caused
all mankind to mourn. They are experiencing the world shattering before
them. Mankind sees the clouds-trouble. Many even discern these drastic
changes as birth pangs that must precede a new world order. As the trouble
intensifies, they will begin to discern the Son of man in the clouds
of trouble and recognize that the "great tribulation" will give birth
to the Kingdom of Christ on earth. While the heavens (nominal churches)
of Matthew 24:29 are experiencing a great shaking, verse 31 shows a
harvest work in progress. "And he [Christ] shall send his angels [messengers]with
a great sound of a trumpet [truth], and they shall gather together his
elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven [nominal churches]
to the other." Zephaniah 1:14, 16 reveals that "the day of the Lord'
is also "a day of the trumpet." This rules out a literal trumpet that
sounds momentarily, and confirms a symbolic trumpet of truth that sounds
for a period of time. Matthew 24:31 describes a great gathering of the
elect, the church (1 Pet. 1:2), that is accomplished by a proclamation
of truth (trumpet) during Christ's presence. This is a reference to
the harvest work at the end of the Gospel Age which is described in
detail in Matthew 13:24-30, 36-43). Here Jesus says that the angels
are the reapers that gather the wheat (faithful Christians). Reapers
do not refer to spirit angels, but to the Lord's people who engage in
the harvest work. Matthew 9:38 Since tares look like wheat, the lesson
is that the angels (messengers of the returned Lord) will do a separating
work, not between the church and the world, but in the nominal church,
the present "heavens." This work is represented under various symbolic
descriptions-it is the gathering of the wheat from the tares into the
barn (Matt. 13:30); it is the gathering of the good fish into baskets
and the casting of the unsuitable fish caught in the gospel net back
into the sea (Matt. 13:47-49); it is the gathering of his jewels (Mal.
3:17); it is the calling of "my people" out of Babylon (Rev. 18:4);
it is the midnight cry to the virgins, which separate the wise from
the foolish (Matt. 25:6); and, in this prophecy, it is the gathering
of the "elect" from all the non-elect of Christendom, from the four
winds-from every quarter. We are not to expect spirit angels to appear
with wings and to fly through the air blowing a great trumpet, and here
and there catching away some of the saints-no more than we are to expect
to become literal fish and to be put into literal baskets, or literal
grains of wheat to be put into a literal barn. The angels or messengers
used by our Lord in this harvest gathering will be such messengers as
he has used in his service throughout this age-earthly servants, begotten
of his holy Spirit, "new creatures" in Christ Jesus. This "gathering
of his elect [the church] from the four winds" means that this gathering
will be accomplished before the four winds are completely loosed and
become a whirlwind. The harvest work will be completed before the whirlwind,
or final feature of the time of trouble, takes place. Also, the elect
are gathered "from one end of heaven to the other," that is, out of
all the nominal churches. The harvest work of Matthew 13 and Matthew
24:31 is the same work of Revelation 18:1-4, where we have already seen
that the returned Christ gathers his faithful people out of Babylon
(heavens, nominal churches), and provides them with a rich spiritual
feast of present truth. Thus we wee that by rightly dividing the word
of Truth-comparing the symbols of Matthew 24:29-31 with symbols in parallel
scriptures- the Bible becomes its own interpreter.
Revelation 1:7
Revelation 1:7 is also often used to prove that
every one will literally see the returned Christ. "Behold, he cometh with
clouds; and every eye shall see (optomai) him, and they also which pierced
him; and all kindreds of the earth shall wail because of him." The word
"see" in the Greek is optomai which we have already seen can mean either
mental perception or literal sight. This verse cannot be taken literally,
since those who literally pierced Jesus have long since died. The Jewish
people living on the earth when Christ returns did not literally pierce
him. If "they which pierced him" is symbolic, then the "clouds" and "every
eye" seeing him must be symbolic. Christ returns in clouds of trouble. As
the time of trouble reaches its climax, every eye, all mankind, will begin
to discern that the trouble is the result of Christ's invisible presence.
"They which pierced him" at Calvary are symbolic of the Jewish people living
at Christ's return. Zechariah 12:10 shows that one of the final features
of the time of trouble will be an invasion of the modern state of Israel.
Their deliverance, by the returned Christ, from this invasion will cause
them to discern that Christ is present. And during the time of trouble,
"all kindreds of the earth shall wail because of him." The time of trouble
is the direct result of Christ's presence. As it grows in severity, all
mankind will lament until they finally discern that it is an evidence of
Christ's presence.
Matthew 26:64
Another scripture sometimes misapplied to
literal sight is Matthew 26:64. Speaking to the High Priest, Jesus said,
"hereafter shall ye see [optomai] the Son of man sitting on the right hand
of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven." Again, the Greek word translated
"see" is optomai, which here means mental perception. If this scripture
is literal, then the High Priest will be living on earth when Christ returns.
This is literally impossible the High Priest Caiaphas was representative
of the whole Jewish nation. And we have seen in the previous scripture that
the returned Lord will be revealed to the Jewish nation in a very special
way during the time of trouble-clouds.
Luke 13:35
Luke 13:35 says "Ye shall not see [eido] me, until the time come
when we shall say, Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord." The
Greek word here translated "see" is eido. It, also, can denote mental
perception or literal sight. (Strong's Concordance defines eido as to see
literally or figuratively.) This Jewish nation was cast off from special
favor by these words of judgment pronounced by Jesus. But as Zechariah 12:10-14
shows, they will repent of their denial of Christ and see (discern) and
experience the second presence of Christ and become a leading nation in
Christ's Kingdom.
Acts 1:11
Acts 1:11 is another scripture sometimes used to prove that the returned
Lord will be seen by the literal eye. "...Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye
gazing up into heaven? this same Jesus, which is taken up from you into
heaven, shall so come in like manner, as ye have seen him go into heaven."
Acts 1:11 does not say as you see the Lord ascend into heaven, so in like
manner shall you see him come again. It does not say that those who saw
him go will see him come, not that anyone else will see him come. What it
does say is that the manner of his coming will be like the manner of his
going. The manner was not with great splendor and great demonstration, trumpet
sounds and voices, a great shout rending the air and the Lord's person shining
in supernatural glory and brightness. But it was quietly, secretly, none
seeing him or knowing of the fact, except his faithful followers. The world
did not see him go, or even know he was going, and they didn't care. Thus,
only the church at first will discern his presence. From a careful consideration
of the scriptures in this appendix it becomes evident that they cannot be
taken literally. They support the concept that all mankind will eventually
see, mentally discern, the invisible presence of Christ.
back
|